Thursday, December 20, 2007
Laurie Hall and the Golden Ticket, Part 1
After I pulled over so I wouldn't crash into anyone, the lady also told me that the prize was only the tickets--I would have to come up with airfare and accomodations. She noticed that I was from California, and told me that she knew it would not be an inexpensive trip, and I could think about it and get back to her. After first determining that she was not, in fact, crazy, I assured her that I would find a way to get there, and I accepted the tickets.
It was torture to decide what to do with the second ticket. Practically everyone I knew would have loved to go. In the end, however, I decided to take my Mom. She really needed the vacation, really wanted to go, and above all, she was here (we got the legal packet with only about a day to have it notarized and sent back to Scholastic's office in NYC!).
Although we would be given copies of Deathly Hallows at the book signing, my Mom and I both decided to buy copies of the special edition to be signed. I certainly don't plan to sell my book, but I'm sure the value is greater having a signature on this more rare edition. I made all the travel arrangements, including a hotel right across the street from Carnegie Hall (which proved highly useful later!), and we were all set to go!
Coming up next: Our trip to New York
Thursday, December 6, 2007
Laurie Meets the Delegation from China
Dr. White did his usual introduction, telling a little about the show, while their guide translated: it shows the wintertime sky and points out several constellations, tells about the cause of the seasons and the meaning of the solstice, tells about several winter holidays and customs, and finally tells a bit about the Star of Bethlehem and the Christmas Story.
At the mention of the Christmas Story, the interpreter got a very puzzled look on his face. "What do you mean by 'The Christmas Story,'" he asked.
At this point, I'm thinking. Okay, there are several possibilities, here. Does he really not know what we're talking about? Has he never heard of the Christmas Story? Is that actually possible? Or is he unsure how to translate it? Or is he unwilling to tranlate it, and starting to worry that he's brought his countrymen to the enemy to be subjected to crazy Christian American propaganda??
So Dr. White says, very calmly, "It's the story of the birth of baby Jesus. There was a special star seen in the sky at that time."
He still seemed slightly puzzled, but he did seem to be able to translate this. And they seemed to enjoy the show. But I'm still burning with curiosity about what was actually going through his head.
And I'd really love to know what he actually said to them in Chinese...
Thursday, November 15, 2007
Our Taxpayer Dollars at Work...
Teacher: It's just $2.50 per person, right?
Me: I'll have to have Kathy talk to you about that. Your show is at 5:00, and we usually charge more for night-time shows. She'll know if a different price was quoted to you.
Teacher: Oh, it's okay. We have a ton of money we have to spend. In fact, if you could charge us $10 a person, that would be great!
Monday, October 29, 2007
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Dessicated Grapes
Wednesday, September 26, 2007
Why I Have a Little Crush On You-Know-Who
I know I’m a Muggle and he’d probably have me killed. But still, the guy speaks some blunt truths about Scrimgeour and Harry Potter that make me swoon…
Okay, I admit it. Part of it is that he’s sort of hot. Possibly hot enough to make me take a Kwikspell course and get a tattoo on my arm. I think he kind of looks like Ralph Fiennes. Sort of. With bad teeth and a more reptilian nose. But that’s not all…
I want to be very clear. There are certainly many things about You-Know-Who that I abhor—murdering of dissidents and Muggles, persecution of werewolves, purging of half-bloods, and, in general, stifling democracy. Even still, I can’t help but be turned on by his frank rhetoric calling out the horrors of Harry Potter, the Scrimgeour administration and, for that matter, generations of Ministry policy preceding.
Recall that, back in June, You-Know-Who sent an owl to Minister for Magic Scrimgeour:
For some time now, I have been thinking, how can one justify the undeniable contradictions that exist… Can one be a supporter of Harry Potter, the great defender of Dumbledore,He goes on:
Feel obliged to respect Muggle rights,
Present liberalism as a civilization model,
Announce one’s opposition to the use of the Unforgivable Curses,
Adopt “Constant Vigilance” as his slogan,
And finally, work towards the establishment of a unified international magical community,
But at the same time,
Call for the attack of Death Eaters. The lives, reputations and possessions of people destroyed and on the slight chance of the presence of a few Death Eaters in a village, city, or convoy for example, the entire village, city or convoy attacked.
Because of the possibility of the existence of a “weapon” in the Department of Mysteries, it is unlawfully surveilled, infiltrated, at least one wizard killed, its infrastructure and architecture destroyed, the sanctity of private prophecies of citizens broken, and important research pushed back perhaps 50 years. At what price? Hundreds of thousands of galleons spent from the treasury of one country and certain other countries and several men and women—many of them very young—put in harm’s way, whisked away from family and loved ones, their hands stained with the blood of others, subjected to so much psychological pressure that those returning home suffer depression; while some are killed and their bodies handed to their families.You-Know-Who, it would appear, cares more about Hogwarts students than Scrimgeour, Dumbledore, or even Harry Potter.
There are prisoners in Azkaban that have not been tried, have no legal representation, their families cannot see them and are obviously kept in a strange place outside their own country. There is no international monitoring of their conditions and fate. No one knows whether they are prisoners, POWs, accused or criminals. I could not correlate the abduction of a person, and him or her being kept in secret prisons, with the provisions of any judicial system. For that matter, I fail to understand how such actions correspond to the values outlined in the beginning of this letter, i.e. the views of Dumbledore, human rights and liberal values.Again, You-Know-Who, who has flagrantly trounced due process and the rule of law time and time again, is still way ahead of Scrimgeour on this point, too.
He then goes on to say that even if many Muggles and half-bloods perished when he originally came to power (a point he concedes in his letter), that doesn’t give Britain the right to displace and terrorize Pure-Bloods. He doesn’t call for violence against half-bloods. He calls for ending violence against Pure-Bloods.
He takes up the charge of other communities struggling for freedom and justice:
Don’t the giants have the right to ask why their elected governments are being opposed and coup leaders supported? Or, why must they constantly be threatened and live in fear?Again, do such actions correspond to the teachings of Dumbledore and the tenets of wizard rights, and the rights of other magical creatures?
The goblins of Britain are hard-working, creative and talented. They can play an important and valuable role in providing for the needs of wizardkind and contribute to its material and magical progress. Poverty and hardship among the goblins are preventing this from happening. Don’t they have the right to ask why their enormous wealth—including armour and weaponry—is being looted, despite the fact that they need it more than others?
He seems to extend genuine condolences for the death of Albus Dumbledore:
Dumbledore’s death was a horrendous incident. The killing of innocents is always deplorable and appalling. My followers and I immediately declared our disgust with the perpetrator and offered our condolences to the bereaved and expressed our sympathies.And yes, he hints at a conspiracy theory that Ministry intelligence forces, as well as others, may have been involved or complicit—but it’s not a huge departure from the findings of the Daily Prophet and our collective recognition that Harry Potter may have got away clean.
You-Know-Who also pins the tail on the Daily Prophet:
After my return, instead of healing and tending to the emotional wounds of the survivors and the British wizarding community, the Daily Prophet only intensified the climate of fear and insecurity—some constantly talked about the possibility of new attacks and kept the people in fear. Is that service to the wizarding community of Britain? British witches and wizards lived in constant fear of fresh attacks that could come at any moment and in any place. They felt insecure in the street, in their place of work and at home. Who would be happy with this situation? Why was the media, instead of conveying a feeling of security and providing peace of mind, giving rise to a feeling of insecurity?He’s accusing the media of being a mouthpiece of Scrimgeour’s warmongering instead of accurately informing the public. Again, this isn’t out there, lunatic, flaming anti-Harry Potter rhetoric. This is simply a powerful and accurate critique of the Ministry—a critique that the Scrimgeour administration would rather silence. Perhaps the Ministry’s campaign against You-Know-Who—just like its previous campaign against Grindelwald and others—isn’t as much about whether he’s a danger to the world. There are plenty of leaders who are more dangerous. And certainly, as Scrimgeour himself illustrates, there are good and bad qualities in all leaders (for the record, Scrimgeour was good on elf rights for a minute).
Could it be that, to Scrimgeour and Harry Potter and their cronies, one of the most dangerous things about You-Know-Who is that he is calling Harry Potter out? And so, if a silencing charm can’t be employed against You-Know-Who, at least he can be discredited. I’m not saying he’s a good guy at all. I’m only saying it’s hard to know the full story when Harry Potter et. al. seem so invested in smearing You-Know-Who—and the Daily Prophet, as we’ve already learned with the Cedric Diggory fiasco, is happy to choose its facts in convenient accordance. Maybe we shouldn’t buy into Potter’s characterization of You-Know-Who as part of his drumbeat escalating toward potential war. Maybe we should listen to You-Know-Who ourselves and sift through what, if anything, is worth hearing.
You-Know-Who ends his letter to Scrimgeour by noting how both their leaderships will be judged by history:
Did we manage to bring peace, security and prosperity for the people or insecurity and unemployment?It’s striking when a leader with an abysmal record for Muggle rights is the one championing the rights of the poor and oppressed to Scrimgeour, who claims to be on the side of Harry Potter, the “Chosen One.” Dangerous indeed—certainly to the status quo he critiques.
Did we intend to establish justice or just support special interest groups, and by forcing many to live in poverty and hardship make a few people rich and powerful?
Did we defend the rights of the underprivileged or ignore them?
Did we defend the rights of all people around the world or impose wars on them, interfere illegally in their affairs, establish hellish prisons and incarcerate some of them?
Did we bring the world peace and security or raise the specter of intimidation and threats?
Did we tell the truth to our people and others around the world, or present an inverted version of it?
Were we on the side of the people or the occupiers and oppressors?
Did we, as leaders, set out to promote rational behavior, logic, ethics, peace, fulfilling obligations, justice, service to the people, prosperity, progress and respect for human dignity; or the force of wands, intimidation, insecurity, disregard for the people, delaying the progress and excellence of other magical peoples, and trample on wizards’ rights?
And finally, they will judge us on whether or not we remained true to our main task—to serve Wizardkind, and the traditions of our ancestors, whose noble blood runs through our veins.
Monday, when You-Know-Who speaks at the Ministry in London, I’ll be listening. Maybe with a bottle of wine and some soft music playing in the background. If I can get past the fact that, as a Muggle, he’d probably have me killed, I’ll try to listen for some truth.
Wednesday, September 19, 2007
Monday, September 17, 2007
Avast, there, mateys!
Ahoy, 'twasn't a requirement t' actually go with the "Talk Like a Pirate" theme (the designs could just be piratey), but me thinks I deserves extra points for bein' one o' the only ones who actually did!
Aye, remember, Talk Like a Pirate Day is this Wednesday, September 19, gar!
(This post was translated with the Talk Like a Pirate Day Pirate Translator)
Monday, September 10, 2007
Marcia, Marcia, Mar...um...Julie!
Or, the piece-de-resistance, the doll-sized Quick Curl Barbie Beauty Center styling head!!
I'm just waiting for the 80's doll...
Wednesday, August 22, 2007
Sunday, August 19, 2007
If Disney did Harry Potter
When you have a little time, take a look through the website. You can look by book or by each individual character. I especially like the large amount of Lupin drawings. He looks much more like I picture him here than he does in the Warner Bros. movies. Enjoy!
Lupin and Neville discussing the boggart:
Dumbledore with a young Tom Riddle:
The artist protesting a shocking lack of Lupin in later books (notice how they all appear to be female...):
Tuesday, August 14, 2007
Monday, August 13, 2007
Harry's Here!
But first, the party! Suzie and I prepared with great enthusiasm. We both have Hogwarts uniforms from Whimsic Alley in L.A. (I highly recommend a trip, if you've never been there), Suzie's from Ravenclaw house, and mine from Gryffindor. Here we are in our uniforms, with wands I found at Borders the night before. Since you can't tell, I must note here that the wands make a magical noise at the push of a button, and the tip of Suzie's lights up in blue and mine in red!
We couldn't resist a friendly duel before we left:
We both also wore our time turners, in case you can't tell what we have around our necks. I brought along a half-finished crocheted elf-hat, and my S.P.E.W. collection tin, complete with sad little solitary galleon someone donated:
We had fun at the party, although they didn't seem to have as much going on as they did at the previous two Borders Harry Potter parties I went to. They had a costume contest, which seemed to be a bit of a joke. The winners had pretty lame costumes, and several people with AMAZING costumes were completely overlooked, such as this woman, dressed as Sibyll Trelawney (with her adorable Gryffindor daughters):
There was also a woman who WAS Molly Weasley, and, my absolute favorite, this fantastic Delores Umbridge costume:
The winner of the contest was pretty amazing, though. He didn't even really come in a costume, unless you count the glasses and the scar drawn on his forehead. He just looked exactly like Daniel Radcliffe:
Around 11:00, Borders announced that they would have employees roving the store with clip boards giving out special prizes. I knew this was my chance. I walked straight up to the first person I saw with a clip board and said, "Ask me some some questions." He had no idea who he was dealing with, obviously, because the first question he asked me was, "What is the spell used to light up the wand tip?" Please. He tried to find a hard one after that, but when I knew the name of the ice cream parlour in Diagon Alley without missing a beat, I think he started to realize he would have to dig a little deeper. He spent several minutes looking for another question. He kept saying, "No, you'll get that...no, that's too easy..." Finally, he found one he thought would stump me. He said, "If you can get this one, you'll get a really special prize." The question was, "What is the 'tickling spell'?" Too easy. (Do you know the answer?) I even knew exactly which scene in which book it was used, and who used it, but I didn't tell him that.
My prize was spot #5 in line!! It was the highest spot given to a trivia question winner, as #1 was a raffle prize, and #2-4 went to the costume contest winners. Very cool. I was able to give my #71 to Suzie, who gave her #121 to Steve Bradley and his family, who we had run into there, and who were hundreds and hundreds of spots down the line. Suzie and I went around listening to more trivia questions, and there wasn't a single one I didn't know! Cool? Or sad? You be the judge. I think I just have a good memory. Yeah, that's it... :-)
Suzie and I got some compliments on our costumes--mostly on the time turners. Everyone wanted to know where we got them. A lot of people also did double takes on the Flourish & Blotts bags, and asked where they were from. One girl ahead of me in line, who was one of the costume contest winners, saw my Flourish & Blotts bag and thought it was cool. I gave her one of my extra bookmarks, and she actually came over and hugged me, she was so excited! It was really cute.
Finally, just before midnight, the Borders employees brought the books into the store.
The excitement in the air was palpable. The whole store did a New Years-esque countdown to midnight, and then the buying frenzy began. I would have been out of there in about 10 seconds, except the idiots running things had forgotten to bring in any of the audio version of the book, so I had to wait several minutes for them to go find them and bring them in. So much for my #5. Finally, I bought my book and CD, and headed home for a long night (and next day) of reading. All in all, a very enjoyable, exciting, and above all, fun experience!
Tuesday, August 7, 2007
Book-Release Morning
Some of them had lawn chairs, and had apparently been waiting since the night before. That was more dedication than even I was willing to muster. Several news channels were there filming us and interviewing people. There were a few people in costume, including these girls in front of me, who came as The Unforgivable Curses ("Crucio" is behind the girl on the right):
Suzie came about half an hour later, dressed in her full Ravenclaw uniform (you'll see pictures later). The line was practically back to the movie theater by then, so I traded places with her in case the news people might want to interview her. They did, of course. She was on the news for several minues, during which time they asked her several trivia questions that displayed her knowledge of the Harry Potter books--and their complete lack of it. The very first question they asked her was "What position does Harry play in 'Kidditch'?" Suzie corrected them and answered all their questions correctly, nicely displaying her Ravenclaw brains.Finally, at 9:00, they started letting us in the store. My wristband was #71--not too bad. But as it turned out, I wouldn't need it after all...
Thursday, August 2, 2007
Saying Goodbye to Harry
I'll start, today, with pre-party preparations. I went to the last two book release parties alone, and spent a fair amount of time sitting around and waiting. Not wanting that to happen again, my first idea was for something fun to bring to do while we were waiting. I looked online for a Harry Potter puzzle book, but couldn't find a good one. So, I decided I'd have to make a trip to Diagon Alley. Flourish and Blotts had this great book--Battling Boredom, by Q. Long-Si. It was full of crossword puzzles, anagrams, logic puzzles, word searches, riddles, poems, and even paper and instructions for making an origami Golden Snitch. A great find, I must say.
Of course, with all those puzzles, we would need something to write with. And what better to write with than a quill? Scrivenshaft's is the only place for quills, so I had to make a trip to Hogsmeade as well.
And, yes, the black one writes in red ink...
While I was in Hogsmeade, I couldn't resist a trip to Honeydukes, the best candy store in the world! I picked up a wide variety of treats, including Bertie Bott's Every Flavor Beans, Smoked Dragon Liver, Drooble's Best Blowing Gum, Exploding Bon-Bons, Licorice Wands, Acid Pops, Jelly Slugs, Sugar Quills, and, of course, Honeyduke's Best Chocolate.
I even got to see them making some fresh Cockroach Clusters. Mmmmm!
All in all, a very productive trip. I'll write more tomorrow about the wait for the book, and the actual Book Release Party itself.
Tuesday, July 31, 2007
Happy Birthday!
Saturday, July 28, 2007
Dear Severus
Dear Severus,
I want to express my condolences on your untimely death. Yes, I know we've never met. Additionally, you are fictional. But in the same way you loved Lily Evans and risked everything in her name, I have always loved you. It was your hatred of children that drew me to you--that, and the fact that you'd never reciprocate my feelings (apparently my No. 1 criterion in choosing men). Some saw your Slytherin loyalties and torment of Harry as signs of betrayal, but my faith in you never wavered, not even when Dumbledore's body lay crumpled and lifeless. You were the bravest wizard who ever lived, and I was yours to the snakebitten end. With your final breath, you wanted to gaze into Lily's green eyes. Oh, how I wish my Muggle blues could have sufficed! I could have saved you. Or at least convinced you to wash your hair. Give my best to Alan Rickman.
xoxo,
Whitney
Thursday, July 26, 2007
Three Cheers for Mary Grand-Pre!
Please, tell me where Dumbledore got his hat! I must know! Oh wait, I see...he's just growing out of the castle.
Here is the Czech version of Philosopher's Stone, in which, apparently, the Sorting Hat is a top hat with giant lips:
But my absolute favorite, I have to say, is this Iranian (Iranian?!) version of Prisoner of Azkaban:
Notice the creepy gargoyle heads on the castle. Notice that Harry looks about 9 years old, and appears to be riding a flying armadillo. But in particular, I ask you to please notice the flying squirrel, the toad, and the tiger. Who are they? How did they come to be there? In Book 5, will Harry show up on Platform 9 3/4 with a tiger padding along behind him, hoping Malfoy won't notice anything funny going on? Or, perhaps, is a toad a grim omen of death in Iranian culture? Who exactly is translating these books? And what, exactly, are they going to do when they get to Book 7...?
Tuesday, July 17, 2007
Giddy
It scares me just a little how excited I am about all this... :-)
Friday, July 6, 2007
Pirate Master Update
Friday, June 29, 2007
Life Imitates Art
The reality show Pirate Master (think Survivor on a pirate ship) features teams of "pirates" in a swashbuckling contest which will ultimately end in a million-dollar buried treasure. Smaller treasures are found each week, and the current Pirate Captain has the option of taking half the treasure for himself, which he is entitled to do, or dividing the money any other way he sees fit.
Monday, June 25, 2007
The Hall Legend lives on...at Hogwarts
I know I picked 'f,' but I can't remember the second choice I picked (maybe 'e'?). Anyway, it was fun. I missed the Grade 1 W.O.M.B.A.T., but took Grade 2 and got an A (Acceptable), so this was a considerable improvement. How sad is it that I was nervous when I opened the the little virtual envelope? Hermione would be proud...12. Which TWO of the following policies do you think would best serve the Ministry of Magic in its fight against the Dark Arts?
a. Destroy all Dark Arts spellbooks
b. Unforgivable Curses to be taught from year 1 at Hogwarts
c. Outlaw sale of all goods that can be used in the Dark Arts
d. Automatic life sentences in Azkaban for all convicted of Dark Arts crimes
e. Improve Ministry of Magic Public Information Services
f. Lift jinx on post of Defence Against the Dark Arts teacher at Hogwarts
g. Persuade Boy Who Lived to front anti-Dark Arts publicity campaign
Friday, June 22, 2007
More Accurate than Sybill Trelawney
One thing I think they should get rid of, however, is the flashing marquee at the top that shows the "thought process" of the game as it sorts through the possible guesses. I think it gives away too much of the sorting process the computer program goes through to arrive at the correct answer, and actually takes away some of the amazement of just seeing the right person, place or thing pop up on the screen without any hint that the game is about to get it right. I would have been much more impressed by the game coming up with "Luna's butterbeer cork necklace," for example, if I hadn't seen it flashing at the top several times before the end of the game.
Bizarre...
Thursday, June 21, 2007
A Kinder, Gentler "War"
Tuesday, June 19, 2007
Laurie and Amy to the Rescue!
Tuesday, June 12, 2007
Tuesday, June 5, 2007
A Shower of Good Fortune
I got a notice on my door yesterday that they were going to replace my water heater. Hooray, right? I can finally take a normal shower and not worry about running out of hot water. So, this morning they show up and start their work, and I'm in the kitchen making my lunch, and I hear this noise that sounds like the shower running.
I'm thinking to myself, "I'm really glad the bathroom is neat, because I didn't know they had to run the shower," when I hear the guy say, "Oh, $#!%!!!"
Not a good sign.
I rush to the hallway and see one of the other guys looking at me like, "Oh great, the tenant would have to be here for this," as he rushes outside, and I hear the first guy say, "I swear I turned it off." There's a steadily growing puddle of water in front of the water heater closet, and the inside--which also includes the air conditioner--is completely drenched.
I have to go to work now, and leave them to finish. What will I find when I return? What new growths of mold and mildew? What lovely new odors? What new stains on my hallway carpet? Only time and the heat of the Fresno summer will tell.
I'm off to make starwheels...
Monday, May 21, 2007
I can't help thinking there's a reason why kids aren't in charge...
The preview ends with the question, "Can they succeed where adults have failed?" I’m curious to know exactly how they think adults have failed. Do they think the United States has failed as a society? I tend to think our society actually functions remarkably well. Has the world failed as a society? Maybe. But I think it would be pretty easy for adults to succeed if their society consisted entirely of intelligent, attractive, psychologically-screened individuals, all from the same national background, and all of whom are trying to win $20,000 by doing their best on a television show. What would make the show really interesting is if they had little child-moles planted in the group, with instructions to steal from the general store, or constantly filibuster at the Town Meetings, or secede from the group, steal all the root beer, and start their own town. Let’s see them deal with that.
The description of the show on CBS’s web site mentions that the grand finale will feature “an unimaginable test, the biggest awards, and a special surprise for every child.” See? They’re all winners. You know, just like in real life.
Monday, May 14, 2007
Why Survivor is still great television
Survivor Finale – SPOILERS
The intensity of the last two episodes of Survivor: Fiji centered around a deal made between two competitors, Yau-Man and Dreamz (I know--who could make up these names?!). Yau-Man gave the truck he had just won to Dreamz, and in return, Dreamz shook his hand and swore to God that if they should both make it to the final four, and if Dreamz should happen to win Immunity, he would give the Immunity necklace to Yau-Man, thus guaranteeing Yau-Man a spot in the final three.
Dreamz quickly realized that the only way to have his cake and eat it too would be to get rid of Yau-Man in one of the two intervening Tribal Councils before he would have to give up his Immunity to him, which would allow him to keep the truck and keep his Immunity without breaking his word. Dreamz was not able to manage this, and we were treated to many heart-to-heart camera interviews in which Dreamz seemed to have come to terms with the fact that, if he won, he would have to honorably hand over his Immunity to Yau-Man. He even stated that he wanted to try hard to win it, so he would have the honor of handing it over, and showing his son what kind of man he was. Dreamz did win the all-important Immunity necklace, and although he showed some signs of having second thoughts, everyone headed off to Tribal Council with the expectation that Dreamz would fulfill his part of the bargain.
But when the moment of truth came, and everyone--perhaps even Dreamz himself--expected Dreamz to hand over the Immunity necklace, he decided to keep it for himself. It was one of the saddest things I’ve ever seen, and not just for Yau-Man, who actually took it very well when he consequently got voted out. Everyone was in shock. Dreamz was crying.
The crazy thing is, Dreamz should have known that it was all over for him at that moment. He may have moved up one place in the rankings, but only a fool would believe that he could win after that. Not only was he the “double agent” who sold out three other jury members, but now he had this shameful display to account for. Several of the jury members at Final Tribal council, as well as host Jeff Probst at the reunion show, tried to give Dreamz a chance to admit that he had accepted the deal in good faith and simply changed his mind, but Dreamz tried to play it as if he had been a master player from the beginning, and breaking Yau-Man’s deal was part of his master plan. This did not sit well with anyone on the jury, who could see that this was obviously not the case. While watching the final Tribal Council, I was riveted by the following exchange between Dreamz and Boo, who was voted out just before Yau-Man:
BOO: First of all, I want to tip my hat off to this man, Yau. I think, by far, he was the greatest all-around player. He relied on this man’s word; Dreamz didn’t come through. You can’t make a promise in your heart, and then say, “Oh, well I changed it now.” [Dreamz], when you made that deal with Yau, were you playing him as a game, or were you, as a Christian—and I’m coming to you with this because I believe in you as a Christian—I want to know your Christian answer. Were you playing him when you accepted that truck, or did you come back later and say, “You know what? I gotta play the game now; this is my chance.”
DREAMZ: [spouts a lot of meaningless crapola]
BOO (interrupting, emphatically): Were you playing the game? As a Christian man, I want your Christian word. When you accepted his truck deal, were you making that as the game, or were you making that because you wanted the truck?
DREAMZ: You don’t know. You don’t know what’s on the inside. I was playing the game. It was going to be me or him. And I thought about it, right here, sitting in this chair. What would everybody else do? Would everybody else give their chance up for a million dollars?BOO (Sad, disgusted): Okay, Dreamz. My opinion? It’s a good try, but I see straight through it. And I still believe in you. But I still believe you’re an immature Christian, and I hope that one day you will be a strong Christian man, and be able to tell the Devil, "Dangle all the money you want in front of me; this Christian is not for sale!"
As strange as it sounds, I think they could have forgiven Dreamz if they had believed his deal had been manipulation from the start. But it was clear the deal was made because he wanted and needed the truck. It was a real-world, honorable deal made in the midst of the game, and when he broke his word, it wasn't simply game-play, it was a breach of honor.
It just goes to show what a difficult line between game and real life the Survivor contestants walk. There's a certain amount of lying and back-stabbing that is seen by all as "part of the game." It may hurt an individual contestant when it causes him to get voted out, but usually all is forgiven by the reunion show at the end of the season. But when the lying and back-stabbing crosses into the real world, as it did with "Jonny Fairplay" and his "dead" grandmother a few seasons back, there is something that makes us cry foul--that makes us believe someone is crossing a line--even if no one is strictly breaking any rules. This deal brought that line into sharper-than-usual focus.